Leaderboard

9red and forst not everyone follows the mc rules down to a key if we did their would be no bending. Now for clear problems while their is no problem making a model voxel It would look alot more appealing and alot more style consistent if u were to make it square.This is a asset that others would use so it would be better to follow the most common style! But! Thier is nothing wrong with making a voxel like pie if its fits your style! That being said while i personally would not use it some others might enjoy it here is a good model would like to see more from you in the future!But keep in mind that if your making these assets for public use to follow a style!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k2s2bPIdE1g This animation took me about 4 months to finish. Hope you like it. (This may be my last music game animation because it takes me a long time to finish and the views are low QAQ)

Locked for nonsense argument, stop downrepping and attacking calm opinion posts, and stop retaliating in response to someone doing that

Jeez, I forgot giving suggestions to creators wasn't allowed. I'll remind Red not to give feedback next time On a serious note, the feedback on Red's input is very disappointing. A lot of the commentators who replied have based their opinions on ill-informed assumptions. I would not like to let this stand unexplained. (Yes, I know I'm late, and there are a lot of comments to catch up with) One of the seemingly common counter-arguments to Red's suggestion is that MC's pumpkin pie item is cylindrical, therefore the 3D model should be allowed to follow that geometry. However, it seems that you haven't drawn the conclusion that MC's item textures are often very different from the actual 3D models used in the game. Minecraft's cake is a great example. Obviously, the item is cylindrical but the 3D object is a square. Thus this counter argument is very flawed, seemingly as it doesn't look at the rest of the game for further information on standards. My point? MC's item textures do not depict the 3D model's geometry. It appears that many of the defending commentators here have made a devastating misconception, believing that Red's statement was in some way "forcing" his style opinion on the creator. However if you actually look at Red's comment, you'll notice that it was actually a suggestion, one that could be denied or accepted depending on the creator's preferences. That is what we do here, after all. After a while, some members were already cancelling Red's suggestion with their own opinions before the creator even got a say in what he wanted to do with the suggestion. It's the creator's choice, not yours. Sure, you can state your opinion, but please don't try to negate someone else's with yours. You don't get to choose what happens with the model either. Maybe offer some of your own suggestions, instead of telling someone else to back off because they attempted to help the creator. Not sure where the "harsh" description came from. The suggestion wasn't harsh at all, just plain and straight to the point with no rudeness. Heck, the suggestion was only 5 words, I'm not sure what's so harsh about that. All other messages sent by Red and I were simply defending the validity of the suggestion. These messages were not even directed to the model or the creator, which is where the assumed "harsh"ness is presumed to be directed to. We weren't even harsh in our defense to the claims that were made. Since when was upholding your own claims considered this preposterous? Your opinion isn't "incorrect", nobody's is. Please don't bring irrelevant self pity into this. Some stated that there was a "flame war" happening in the topic, when in reality Red and I had backed off the field while everyone else attacked the suggestion. A very one-sided flame war, if anything. Once again, we never forced the creator to change anything, it was only a suggestion. Now about "Filled with such things", since when was suggesting considered a bad thing? I'd rather the forums not leave behind users suggesting things to creators. Honestly confused as to where the description "pissy" came from, as far as I remember, suggesting an alternative wasn't labeled as "pissy". Both Red and I acted respectfully while defending the suggestion's validity. Kinda disappointing to hear this come from MI's Visual Designer ? Our intention was not to make the creator feel bad, it is obviously not expected for them to get upset about a suggestion. I have a feeling this might've branched off from all the negativity to Red's comment, possibly giving a skewed perception to the creator. Definitely would've helped if you all hadn't attacked it ? Funny how you mention "mass-downvoting", while your opposing side downvoted significantly more than Red and I ever did. You don't have much room to talk. Once again you claim that our comments are "harsh". I touched on this earlier. Since when was calmly suggesting things considered "toxic"? Neither Red nor I ever stated that the model was ever "wrong". Red's suggestion wasn't a complaint; there's a difference. The funny thing is that Red and I stopped replying fairly early, even before the wave of overly-defensive and ill-informed comments arrived. I don't like making long posts like these, but I wanted to make some things clear. This post was not directed at the creator or the model itself; it is directed at the users mentioned. It honestly saddens me to see the community attack such simple suggestions like this ?

Ah yes, getting pissy and arguing because a pie model looks like the in-game sprite. Never change, MIF!

this is the stupidest mini drama ive ever seen on the forums

Imagine being so against one thing not precisely being in the Minecraft style that you bash on the work to the point of making the creator feel terrible and regret posting it, while additionally mass-downvoting everyone who even dares to disagree with your harshness. No wonder people consider this community to be toxic. Hope you're real proud of yourselves.

I made a Pie model, simple as that. Includes Alt Textures for Various pies (or you can make one yourself.) IMAGES: https://ibb.co/9pxsHMD https://ibb.co/jTTNMxb https://ibb.co/gvDLQBr DOWNLOAD

Not everything has to "look like minecraft" bub. Let people make what they want to make. Restrictions like these are what kill communities. You are contributing to the death of this community

Minecraft is so inconsistent in it's style that this fits fine. This looks fantastic actually.

What the heck is even going on here? Its absurd. Voicing your opinion on a rig Is one thing, but some of you seem to saying he made it wrong. As if there's some sort of 'correct' way to make a pie in Mine-imator. The guy made a rig, and if you don't like the way he made it get over it and move on with your life.

Lord what had happened here? @TheRealMariobros1045, don’t worry, your pie model looks delicious! It’s just that not everyone agrees with your style, and sometimes it would be nice for you to use the square pattern, but whenever you feel you should make sometime ‘voxel’, don’t be afraid! Can’t believe this forum still is filled with such things and can’t leave it behind smh

I've Been gone for Hours and I come back to a Mini Flame war.... and This is why I regret post crap most of the time...

I've never seen either of you being this against a rig/model of this style before, despite hundreds of them existing. Some of which are much worse than this one. You're acting like he made it out of cylinders or something. Calm down. EDIT: Thanks for all the downvotes, you two... guess that's what I deserve for having another incorrect opinion, huh.

It really feels like you're nit-picking here, if I'm honest. I see nothing wrong with the model.

Decided to look around and try to find all the old stuff I made, and stupidly deleted. I got a couple of clips ?. Hope you enjoy!

so I was bored, and wanted to imagine what would an Underwater City looks like in the deepest part of the Ocean where there is no sunlight, pitch black.

why is this still going this is over a damn 3D Pie. i see both sides, but y'all are acting like 5 year olds arguing if the sun is a star or a planet, although the square side is more convincing due to the fact they arent acting like actual children.

You guys fight over voxels, how absolutely pathetic.

Disney shill

Exterior model is finished and so the exterior of the Time Machine mod.

I can confirm, I forgot about it

This is just amazing! Great job. Sadly I am out of reactions.

Did a simplistic render testing the new face rig me and frost made.

this has become SharpWinds average topic

just asking, when did red ever say this model was "wrong"? he just said it didn't fit with mc's style and said mc isn't a voxel game.(which it isn't)

Minecraft's in-game pumpkin pie is round in the texture so your point makes no sense. Not everything has to be exactly minecraft, geez, let people explore some styles freely without nitpickings things like this. It's a good looking rig. I'd rather use this rig than a square pumpkin pie ngl.

fire looks lit(erally), id recomend if you want glowy eyes tho, use a 3D glasses, but this looks awesome dude

The Lighting Must be Advanced. The Glasses I recomended Change Into 3D Model. The Sky Looks Nice!

Reminds me of Dig Build Live It looks pretty good imo

Well render I made for PigManMovie contest theme is halloween character I used as the title headless horseman rig is by me I hope you like it :D

Yesterday was @9redwoods birthday, so I made him this gift. Was intending on finishing it yesterday, but the set took longer than expected ? But it is here Homies here are (from left to right) @ShotU, @Phyre, @Frost (me), @9redwoods (birthday man), @MikTRF, @DragonPixel and @Cubic Ralsei. If you're interested, here's the set I made for it Thank you Red for being a great friend ? You deserve all these wishes

Its because of the limits from where mine-imator was created. Game maker. Reflections are possible in mine-imator but are excruciatingly hard to make

that's fan made, and this is f n a f ar smh

OwO

wanted to make a "joy of creation" pun but Eh

HAHAHAHAHAHA no

he seems to be joyful of his creations

I love it, keep up the good work

download link(don't forget to credit me ): download link: https://www.dropbox.com/s/nbolontzzxnjceu/climb the ladder - by zebddymations.keyframes?dl=0

He made a suggestion.

I'd suggest making it square.

This just doesn't fit with minecraft. Minecraft isn't a voxel game, and this pie model is very voxelized and has a high surface count. It just doesn't match anything. Here's a good reference to go off of when it comes to modeling round objects.

Minecraft does not use voxels to model blocks, entities, or items. The only way you can relate Minecraft to voxels is the shape of the blocks used to make it up. Minecraft is not a voxel game.

minecraft isn't made out of voxels ?.