Mine-imator VS Cinema 4D Comment of what you think.

[Creepercraft 58]

Mine-imator:

Pros: Very user friendly, Simple and usefull.

 

Cinema 4D:

Pros: User Friendly, Simple to learn and High Quality Rendering

 

Comment on your opinion!

 

[CarlHeadCrashed 1k]

Mine-Imator

[xXKanyeXx 61]

Mine-Imator

[MineRocker Animations 1.4k]

I'd say Mine-imator is great but you need to put a lot of work to get almost C4D quality in it.

But.. C4D is better when you consider bigger projects or archieving pro. quality.

[RobotCoveredWithHumanFlesh 2k]

Definitely C4D. It is made for professional animation. It is much more powerful.

 

But it is not easy to learn, nor user friendly. You could easily memories how to move around objects, or extrude them, but all the features? Good luck.

[Allemn 2.6k]

Both!!!

[Mr. Cat 1.2k]

Mine-Imator for me. But sometimes i'm pressing alt while working in MI.

[SKIBBZ 9.1k]

Mine-Imator

 

I like simple things. 

[abdelkrim 43]

Mine-imator is perfect for minecraft animation

you can import a lot of schematics and other

You can create animation pro in this (look Skibbz or other)

And I prefer Blender to C4D

[flufffybuns 926]

Mine-imator:

Simple, doesn't cost any money, and it makes all the Minecraft models for you.

 

Cinema 4D:

I think it costs money, you need to make the models yourself, but renders high quality.

 

 

I still vote for Mine-imator.

[david 8.4k]

C4D

[Cryotivity 2.9k]

I hate all 3d programs camera systems

 

But Mineimators is actually good so mine-imator.

[abdelkrim 43]

C4D

the creators said this!!!

[Kreuzer 2.6k]

when it comes to render thingy i'd say C4 but i got used to MI so i'll stick to it

[Creepercraft 58]

Mine-imator:

Simple, doesn't cost any money, and it makes all the Minecraft models for you.

 

Cinema 4D:

I think it costs money, you need to make the models yourself, but renders high quality.

 

 

I still vote for Mine-imator.

I know how to get stuff like that for free

[Mr. Cat 1.2k]

C4D

[MinesterTheFloop 203]

C4D

WAT

 

EDIT: Mine-imator. Cinema 4D is expensive. SUPER EXPENSIVE. 

Edited April 7, 2015 by TheMinester

[Phupha 1.2k]

Mine-Imator

[MrPizzaCat 456]

Blender

Mine-Imator

Edited April 7, 2015 by Almost200Ninjas

[myluki2000 431]

Do we REALLY need to discuss this AGAIN??!!

[MinecraftRedstonerds 87]

C4D; I have no clue how you said it was easy. Only the basics are actually that simple. Most Minecraft animations just don't require the knowledge.

[Paul Sheldon 2.5k]

Its kinda unfair to compare a more advanced, and more..um...open source animation software to a easy to use animation software that only focuses on minecraft. 

 

If your going to compare C4D to something, compare it to something that meets the quality of it.

 

(I learned this the hard way )

Edited April 8, 2015 by TheSpiderRider

[Oddities 316]

Mine-Imator is free, easy to use, get the hang of it and your animations are god and thiey don't take long, whilst C4D take some time to animate and make wallpapers out of and it costs ALOT of money, so I would say MI.

[Derpyanimator 0]

Mine-imator 

[EnderDudeGaming 8]

Mine-imator:

 

Easy to use. No need to install a minecraft rig, because it's a minecraft animation software in the first place lol. Very easy to model new rigs, because its so simple to scale them. If you're using Mine-Imator, you can still get fairly high-quality rendering, and if you use other programs to brighten it up, it could look pretty close to C4D.

 

Cinema 4D:

 

A bit more difficult to use, but very useful for high-quality rendering. Cinema 4D is also able to do more than just minecraft of course, but we're talking about minecraft animations here. You will need to download some rigs, just to get the minecraft objects in there, But you could also make your own rigs. There's of course face rigs for download somewhere on the internet, but in mine-imator, you could get plenty of useful rigs, or make your own. I made mine. Thanks to people like GasCreeper, he's released a full working player rig with fingers and everything. I think mine-imator is easiest, but cinema 4D looks better in final rendering.

 

Conclusion:

 

Of course we all know that mine-imator is still in beta, but the 1.0.0 demo is out. We know that David probably has some very useful plans coming soon. Overall, I choose Mine-Imator over cinema, just because it's easy to use,  and if you want to model something yourself, its as simple as just adding objects like cubes, spheres, cylinders, etc. By the way, this is just in my opinion. You might feel different about what I think. Also, mine-imator is a free program, while cinema costs A FORTUNE.