I don't understand why people like keeping things unedited. Sure, it gives them bragging rights and all, but it's just them keeping themselves at a level they can't pass without editing.
Also, whoever says editing makes wallpapers look worse, take a look at my spiderman wallpaper. Editing was needed for more of that comic book feel, and it's not overboard. Actually, it's very subtle.
The person who said "Editing makes it worse" meant that if you go overboard it looks bad or if you dont need to edit it but you edit anyways then it looks bad.